Cytotoxic evaluation of a mixture of eight pollutants at environmental relevant concentrations / Evaluación de la citotoxicidad de una mezcla de ocho contaminantes a concentraciones de relevancia ambiental

The ubiquitous presence of pollutants and the accurate evaluation of their potential risks for environmental and human health is an area of major concern. We have simulated an in vitro scenario of long-term exposure to a mixture of eight pollutants at real environmental concentrations using mammalian Vero cells. Our results demonstrate that cellular proliferation rates were significantly altered, either by inhibition or stimulation, depending on the mixture composition and the exposure time. We encourage the urgency of reviewing safety levels for emerging contaminants accepted by regulatory agencies, considering that mixtures of pollutants represent a threat for environmental and human health (AU)

La presencia ubicua de contaminantes ambientales y la adecuada evaluación de su riesgo potencial para la salud humana y ambiental es un área de gran preocupación. En este trabajo se ha simulado un escenario in vitro de exposición a largo plazo de una mezcla de ocho contaminantes a concentraciones reales presentes en el medio ambiente, utilizando la línea celular de mamífero Vero. Nuestros resultados demuestran que se alteran significativamente las tasas de proliferación celular, ya sea por estimulación o inhibición, dependiendo de la composición de la mezcla y del tiempo de exposición. En vista de estos resultados, recalcamos la necesidad de revisar los niveles de seguridad aceptados por las agencias reguladoras para contaminantes emergentes, teniendo en cuenta que las mezclas de contaminantes representan una amenaza para la salud humana y medioambiental (AU)

Toxicological evaluation of three contaminants of emerging concern by use of the Allium cepa test.

Di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate, triclosan and propylparaben are contaminants of emerging concern that have been subjected to extensive toxicological studies, but for which limited information is currently available concerning adverse effects on terrestrial plant systems. The Allium cepa test, which is considered one of the most efficient approaches to assess toxic effects of environmental chemicals, was selected to evaluate the potential risks of these ubiquitous pollutants. Our data demonstrate that all three compounds studied may in some way be considered toxic, but different effects were noted depending on the chemical and the end point analysed. Results derived from the analysis of macroscopic parameters used in testing for general toxicity, revealed that while di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate had no apparent effects, the other two chemicals inhibited A. cepa root growth in a dose-dependent manner. On the other hand, although all three compounds caused alterations in the mitotic index of root-tip cells, propylparaben was the only one that did not show evidence of genotoxicity in assays for chromosome aberrations and micronuclei. The results of the present study clearly indicate that sensitive plant bioassays are useful and complementary tools to determine environmental impact of contaminants of emerging concern.

An integrated cellular model to evaluate cytotoxic effects in mammalian cell lines.

The ever growing anthropogenic pressure to the environment has lead in 2007 to the revision of the existing legislation and the approval of the new European law regarding the production and importation of chemicals, known as REACH. This new legal framework supports the development of alternative methods to animal experimentation encouraging the improvement and/or design of new methodological strategies for the toxicological evaluation of chemical compounds. Even though cytotoxicity studies are a reductionist approach to acute toxicity in vivo, they offer the best agreement between obtaining relevant information about the mechanism of toxic action and the use of alternative methods. Following this trend, this work presents an integrated cellular strategy in order to know the toxicity and mechanism of action of chemical compounds, using simple and reproducible in vitro systems. The experimental procedures are performed in two steps. The first one involves the systematic analysis of the main cellular targets using proliferation, viability and morphological probes. The second step relies upon the results obtained in the first step, including specific assays that focus on the mechanism of toxic action and the cellular response. The benefits of this strategy are exemplified with two real cases: pentachlorophenol and rotenone.

In vitro assessment of the cytotoxic and mutagenic potential of perfluorooctanoic acid.

Perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) is a perfluorinated compound ubiquitously detected in the environment, including wildlife and humans. Despite the available information, research on the cytotoxicity of PFOA in non-tumoral mammalian cells is relatively limited. In this work, two in vitro toxicity systems were employed to provide further insight into the cytotoxic and mutagenic potential of PFOA. The cytotoxicity of the chemical towards Vero cells was assessed using biochemical and morphological parameters, while mutagenicity was evaluated according to Ames test. High doses of PFOA cause oxidative stress in Vero cells, that was closely linked to cell cycle arrest at the G1 phase and induction of apoptosis. Our results corroborate previous findings in human tumoral cells and suggest that the mode of action of this perfluorinated compound is not a peculiarity among mammalian cell types. On the other hand, the compound was not mutagenic in the Ames test, using four strains of Salmonella typhimurium in the presence or absence of rat S9 metabolic activation system.

Carbamazepine induces mitotic arrest in mammalian Vero cells.

We reported recently that the anticonvulsant drug carbamazepine, at supratherapeutic concentrations, exerts antiproliferative effects in mammalian Vero cells, but the underlying mechanism has not been elucidated. This motivates us to examine rigorously whether growth arrest was associated with structural changes in cellular organization during mitosis. In the present work, we found that exposure of the cells to carbamazepine led to an increase in mitotic index, mainly due to the sustained block at the metaphase/anaphase boundary, with the consequent inhibition of cell proliferation. Indirect immunofluorescence, using antibodies directed against spindle apparatus proteins, revealed that mitotic arrest was associated with formation of monopolar spindles, caused by impairment of centrosome separation. The final consequence of the spindle defects induced by carbamazepine, depended on the duration of cell cycle arrest. Following the time course of accumulation of metaphase and apoptotic cells during carbamazepine treatments, we observed a causative relationship between mitotic arrest and induction of cell death. Conversely, cells released from the block of metaphase by removal of the drug, continued to progress through mitosis and resume normal proliferation. Our results show that carbamazepine shares a common antiproliferative mechanism with spindle-targeted drugs and contribute to a better understanding of the cytostatic activity previously described in Vero cells. Additional studies are in progress to extend these initial findings that define a novel mode of action of carbamazepine in cultured mammalian cells.

Cytotoxicity of butylated hydroxyanisole in Vero cells.

Butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA) is perhaps the most extensively used synthetic antioxidant in the food and cosmetic industry, although considerable controversy exists in the literature regarding the safety of this compound. Most in vitro studies describing the effects of BHA have been performed in cancer cells, but it is unclear whether normal cells are equally susceptible to BHA exposure. The present study investigate the toxic potential of BHA in mammalian cells, using biochemical and morphological parameters, which reveal interference with structures essential for cell survival, proliferation and/or function. Cell growth inhibition was assessed by using colorimetric assays, whereas cellular alterations after BHA exposure, were evaluated using conventional light and fluorescence microscopy. Low doses of BHA exerted a significant cytotoxic effect, associated with loss of mitochondrial function. As the concentration of BHA was increased, morphological alterations in critical subcellular targets such as lysosomes, mitochondria and actin cytoskeleton, were observed. In parallel, BHA induced an irreversible loss of cell proliferative capacity, preceding apoptosis induction. Thus, the dose-dependent activity of BHA on Vero cells appears to be cytotoxic as well as cytostatic. Our observations, although simplified with respect to the in vivo situations, allowed the assessment of the specific damage at the cellular level, and provide some clue about the effects of BHA in non-tumoral mammalian cells.

Cytotoxic effects in mammalian Vero cells exposed to pentachlorophenol.

The effects of pentachlorophenol have been studied on diverse biological systems both in vivo and in vitro, however the cellular basis of the pronounced cytotoxicity of this organochlorine compound is poorly understood. In this work, morphological and biochemical analyses were carried out to identify the primary targets of pentachlorophenol toxicity in mammalian cells. Our results show that pentachlorophenol is a very potent cytotoxic drug that displays an unusual and interesting mode of action in Vero cells. Although this compound is a powerful uncoupler of oxidative phosphorylation, we present the novel finding that lysosome destabilization is an early cytotoxic response that precedes the mitochondrial dysfunction. In addition, soon after exposure to moderate doses of pentachlorophenol, a significant number of cells initiate an apoptotic death process identified by the condensed and fragmented state of their nuclei. These results demonstrate that there are multiple potential targets of PCP-induced toxicity in mammalian cells, and the need to develop further experimental studies for the risk assessment of this environmental pollutant.

Ultrastructural changes induced in HeLa cells after phototoxic treatment with harmine.

In the present work, we have continued our studies on harmine phototoxicity in human tumour cells. The toxicity of harmine in the dark was analysed by a quantitative neutral red uptake assay, and subcellular sensitive targets following harmine photosensitization were de fi ned by electron microscopic analysis of HeLa cells. The results obtained indicated that this compound shows a clear dose-dependent cytotoxic effect in the dark. The combined treatment with suitable doses of harmine and UV radiation was very effective at an early stage, although maximal cell killing appeared 48 h after photodynamic activation. Ultrastructural examination of HeLa cells immediately after the photodynamic treatment revealed lysosomal destabilization and profound cytoplasmic vacuolization that evolved to cytolysis, which is typical of necrotic cell death. It is concluded that harmine could be a valuable photosensitizer whose biological applications merit further evaluation.

Ecotoxicological evaluation of carbamazepine using six different model systems with eighteen endpoints.

The occurrence of pharmaceutically active compounds in the aquatic environment has been recognized as one of the emerging issues in environmental chemistry. However, the ecotoxicological effects of pharmaceuticals have still not been researched adequately. Carbamazepine, an anticonvulsant commonly present in surface and groundwater, was studied, using six ecotoxicological model systems with eighteen endpoints evaluated at different exposure time periods. The battery included the immobilization of Daphnia magna, bioluminescence inhibition in the bacterium Vibrio fischeri, growth inhibition of the alga Chlorella vulgaris, and micronuclei induction and root growth inhibition in the plant Allium cepa. Cell morphology, neutral red uptake, total protein content, MTS metabolization, lactate dehydrogenase leakage and activity and glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase activity were studied in the salmonid fish cell line RTG-2. The total protein content, LDH activity, neutral red uptake and MTT metabolization in Vero monkey kidney cells were also investigated. The most sensitive system to carbamazepine was the Vero cell line, followed by Chlorella vulgaris, Vibrio fischeri, Daphnia magna, Allium cepa, and RTG-2 cells. EC50 values from 19 microM in Vero cells at 72 h to more than 1200 microM in other systems, were obtained. Comparing the concentrations in water and the toxicity quantified in our assay systems, carbamazepine is not expected to produce acute toxic effects in the aquatic biota under these circumstances, but chronic and synergistic effects with other chemicals cannot be excluded.